Boundaries as domain shadows

May 28, 2017

I’ve been teaching a masterclass her in India to a mixed group and took the opportunity to push myself to get the boundaries as domains version of Cynefin to a point where it could be published for comment and start to develop. I’ve been playing with it for around three months now which a fairly typical gestation time for any new framework or idea. It’s a matter of making sure it passes the napkin test; is coherent to the theory and provides utility for sense-making. I managed it today by drawing the framework then simply adding or extending existing lines and it all came together in two stages, one before and other during lunch; Twitter followers will have seen the iterations.

I’d been thinking about creating a version of Cynefin in which the complex-complicated boundary becomes a domain. The reason for that is a lot of techniques, for example a sprint within Scrum, are boundary transitions rather than domain techniques. In general any linear iteration or experiment is such a transition rather than a domain technique. Complex is about shorter cycle parallel probes. Maintaining a project within the boundary domain is important to prevent premature convergence, so it needs to be more than a line. Over the last couple of days I’ve been thinking of it less as a domain more as a gradient or shadow – which is how it is drawn here.

So the convention is fairly simply, we have three new elements:

  • A dark shaded area generally clockwise of the boundary which is effect is a holding space, a shadow, a period where you have crossed the boundary but are not fully committed.
  • Green shaded is narrower, steeper, such transitions need a change of practice.
  • Red is a danger sign, a cross only if you really mean it.

Then within the shadow areas themselves:

  • Complicated to complex is a shift from linear to parallel experiments for example.
  • Shifting from best practice to good practice (Obvious to Complicated) opens up to governing constraints with variety not one way of doing things  ….
  • …while a transition the other way can be done more experimentally, withdrawal is still possible.
  • Entering Chaos is a definitive decision, working on the edge of chaos in the complex domain means the patterns are sort of there, far from clear but starting to form and formal safe-to-fail experiments should be more transitory in nature.
  • The Obvious to Chaotic boundary should be a barrier. climbing back up the cliff is hard.

Disorder is interesting, working on that

So open for comment ….

… and just to be clear, this is a Cynefin extension, not a new Cynefin




PS: My resolution to write a daily blog post stimulated by whatever came in from Gaping Void didn’t survive an accumulation of back email to 800+ and a pretty punishing travel schedule. But I like the idea and may return to it in June and use the weekdays for that leaving the weekend, where there are no mailers for other material.

5 responses to “Boundaries as domain shadows”

  1. Sherry Johnson says:

    At the moment I’m imagining staircases of varying types between the domains. Obvious to complicated is a narrow stairway downward. Complicated to complex is a set of parallel stairs. Complex to chaotic is a set of switchback stairs that shift occasionally, a la Harry Potter. And between chaos and simple is a dodgy elevator whose pullies throw out sparks.

  2. Akshay Anand says:

    You could apply the shadow area concept anti-clockwise of the boundaries. Is there a reason you chose not to do so? For example, I would suggest there is a danger of entering a holding pattern going from Complex to Complicated (e.g. due to FOMO), or from Complicated to Obvious (e.g. due to experts resisting oversimplification of their expertise)

  3. Mitch Weisburgh says:

    I’m thinking that in going from one domain to another there is both a decision and a situation. You can decide to move from using tools of the complex domain to those of the complicated one. But also the situation itself could be changing due to the emergence of better tools and/or a change in environment (or something else). Should a model take that into account?

    • Dave Snowden says:

      Agree its both, what I am working on is the nature of a transition and the associated decision – is it a sharp change, deliberate act or can it be more transitory. Next iteration up soon

  4. Dr Wendy Eford says:

    Right now I am thinking of my history as a white water kayaker and hydrotopography. I am a fan of metaphors and will work on sketching this. My all time favourite book on this is William Nealy’s Kayak: the animated manual of intermediate and advanced whitewater technique.

    Think different types of rapids on a river with lake as a source. I am not wanting to think of this as linear. but more of a landscape / waterscape. As any canyoner or rambler knows, up and down and around the river is possible if you don’t mind getting wet and have the right skills, tools and mindset.

    Also think in terms of the dynamics of water flowing around a rock in a river – the cushion or pillow on the upstream side and the turbulence and still water behind the rock on the downstream side.

    Obvious to / from complicated

    Think lake to pebble race for the transition. Starts to break up the pattern between a still water section in small transitions across the boundary. Still able to walk back and forth as water is shallow /moving slowly and rocks stable enough.

    Complicated to / from complex

    Think grade 2-3 rapid. More of a scramble over larger rocks to get back and more difficult transition downstream. Accidents are possible. Greater commitment is needed but the amateur can make the shift so still safe to fail.

    Complex to chaos

    Think serious Grade 4-5. Scouting the boundary is essential as the risk of failure is much greater, hence more skill is needed. Studying the boundary gives a sense of the patterns which will deliver success in the transition into the turbulence. Commitment is the key to success but it is possible to drift into the current and end up in the turbulence without control. Retreat is possible but more technical.

    Obvious to chaos

    Waterfall. Looked great until you went over the edge. Scouting the boundary and knowing how you will hold your form in the transition and then land and recover is essential. Support for beginners is unlikely to be enough unless this is highly skilled and the circumstances set up well.

    The science of hydrodynamics would deliver more at a microlevel in terms of understanding how patterns within a smaller section of the boundary would operate.

    Buffer zone

    This is the place where the water hits the rock. It is a place of uncertainty but can be stable enough to observe from, though transition back into the current is not guaranteed. Once observations are made, going upstream for a run up is a better plan.

    Eddy fences, holes and many other features deserve more description than I will give here

    If interested, Nealy’s book will absolutely be food for thinking. https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/e8293e39496543109396294ec25f0037bb07ef55210c9d8934db39ab1a9908d4.jpg

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

About the Cynefin Company

The Cynefin Company (formerly known as Cognitive Edge) was founded in 2005 by Dave Snowden. We believe in praxis and focus on building methods, tools and capability that apply the wisdom from Complex Adaptive Systems theory and other scientific disciplines in social systems. We are the world leader in developing management approaches (in society, government and industry) that empower organisations to absorb uncertainty, detect weak signals to enable sense-making in complex systems, act on the rich data, create resilience and, ultimately, thrive in a complex world.

Cognitive Edge Ltd. & Cognitive Edge Pte. trading as The Cynefin Company and The Cynefin Centre.

© COPYRIGHT 2022. 

Social Links: The Cynefin Company
Social Links: The Cynefin Centre
< Prev

the right Promethean fire

- No Comments

Love is one of those words which has so many meanings in differencing contexts that ...

More posts

Next >

Liminal Cynefin


The Cynefin framework tends to be used in the main to categories situations within the ...

More posts

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram